No claim is made here that public schools are perfect or cannot be improved. However, there is a widely held belief that our nation's public schools have failed. "A Public Defense of the Public Schools" responds to this flawed conviction.
Our public schools have NOT failed, yet for decades an organized attack has existed to convince Americans that they have.
Our public schools have NOT failed, yet for decades an organized attack has existed to convince Americans that they have.
The next paragraph explains the reason for this attack and everything after that is directed against the misinformation and disinformation of the attackers.
The attack on schools is about money. $700 billion is the annual expenditure for America's elementary/secondary public schools (local, state, federal spending). That's a HUGE chunk of money. National defense spending is $600 billion (all federal money). Private interests want at that $700 billion so they are promoting a for-profit voucher/school choice/charter system that would siphon much of that public money into billions of dollars of private profits. Of course, to shift the nation to a for-profit public school system, people first need to be convinced, through a sustained and well-funded propaganda attack, that their public schools have failed.
THE DEFENSE
FALSE CLAIM: Charter schools, school choice and vouchers will fix the broken public school system.
Evidence produced in peer reviewed research has
consistently and conclusively shown little difference in success
rates between charter and public schools. Proponents of charter schools produce attractive
websites, conferences, and publications designed for the media and the policy
maker but their research is limited, often
overstated, often based on suspect methodology, and largely outside the normal
system of academic review.
There may be little difference between charter and public schools when it comes to achievement but there is a GREAT difference in just about everything else. Charter schools are exempt from many of the requirements and standards of most public schools. This is largely due to the way the charter industry has been built by proponents, favoring "flexibility" over rules. That flexibility has allowed an epidemic of fraud, waste, and mismanagement that would not be tolerated in public schools. Charters are often policed—if they are really policed at all—by charter proponents, both within government agencies and within private entities tasked with oversight as "authorizers" of charters. Much of the info in this paragraph is from the first two links below
As for school choice, giving tax vouchers for parents to use in private schools sounds good but the reality is quite different. Louisiana passed a sweeping voucher/choice law aimed at becoming the model every state would copy but it was ruled unconstitutional because the law left huge loopholes for private schools to engage in discriminatory practices. The law also allowed private schools to have little accountability for their achievement and spending. The last link below is a great summary of what happened in Louisiana as well as a clear look at the nationwide problems of the voucher/choice idea.
Link to: Lack of charter school oversight/accountability
Link to: Charter school vs. public school information
FALSE CLAIM: Our public schools fail to produce an adequately prepared workforce.
Our country leads the world in worker productivity. American workers lead the world in hours, days, and overtime worked per year. The U.S. still has the largest economy in the world and although China overtook the U.S. as the world's largest manufacturing
nation in 2010, the production margin between the two countries is
razor-thin (even though China has four times as many people as the U.S.). Oh, and it's a myth that our schools produce a lack of technologically skilled workers. That's baloney and an excuse for outsourcing high-tech jobs overseas. U.S. public schools produce technologically skilled workers but jobs for them have vanished because foreign workers work for 75% to 90% less than what the same job pays in the U.S.
Link to: Overseas outsourcingFALSE CLAIM: Government reports indicate that our public school system has failed.
"A Nation at Risk", the highly publicized, non-scientific government report from 1983 had a predetermined negative conclusion and was politically motivated. Why cite a report from almost 35 years ago? Because "A Nation at Risk" arguably launched the attack on public schools, the same attack occurring to this day.
The scientifically conducted 1990 "Sandia Report", which showed no system wide public school crisis, was never released by the government because "catastrophically failing schools had become a political necessity".
Link to: "A Nation at Risk" and "Sandia Report" information
FALSE CLAIM: NAEP results continue to indicate that public school students are not proficient.
Our federal government's NAEP (National Assessment of Educational Progress), nicknamed our "Our Nation's Report Card", consistently shows negative results. However, unbiased agencies criticize NAEP for using harsh, unrealistic and unfair measurements of student proficiency in order to promote an anti-public school agenda. Such a bias was acknowledged because NAEP findings now include a disclaimer to not take NAEP proficiency levels too seriously and that scientific panels have concluded NAEP results should be "interpreted with caution".
FALSE CLAIM: NAEP results continue to indicate that public school students are not proficient.
Our federal government's NAEP (National Assessment of Educational Progress), nicknamed our "Our Nation's Report Card", consistently shows negative results. However, unbiased agencies criticize NAEP for using harsh, unrealistic and unfair measurements of student proficiency in order to promote an anti-public school agenda. Such a bias was acknowledged because NAEP findings now include a disclaimer to not take NAEP proficiency levels too seriously and that scientific panels have concluded NAEP results should be "interpreted with caution".
Link to: Interpreting NAEP results
FALSE CLAIM: Public schools are failing because tenure laws protects bad teachers.
In most school districts tenure is not granted until 5 years of teaching have been completed. Certainly by that time an incompetent teacher should have been identified.
Teacher tenure only ensures a teacher be given a fair hearing before getting fired. However, public school attackers have made "tenure" a dirty word. A majority of respondents, when asked in a Zogby Poll if they supported tenure, respond with, "No". However, when asked if they supported replacing tenure with a system where a teacher received a fair hearing before a school board could fire them, 84% of respondents replied with a strong, "Yes". Of course what respondents said "yes" to was a basic definition of teacher tenure.
FALSE CLAIM: U.S. students have fallen far from the top of the world rankings.
U.S. students were never at or near the top on international comparisons and such comparisons are arguably meaningless.
With so many variables, a valid comparison of students from various countries is a tricky and statistically challenging analysis.
Actually, just about any conclusion, good or bad, regarding American public school students and their international ranking can be drawn using selective data and/or biased interpretations. Foes of American public schools often use singular hand-picked results to support their "school crisis" rhetoric.
The two links posted below give a great understanding of the complexity and perhaps the futility of trying to make accurate statements about U.S. students vs. their international counterparts.
Link to: What international tests really show
Link to: Important considerations regarding international test scores
FALSE CLAIM: America outspends all other nations on public schools yet still has nothing to show for it.
As for poor results, refer to the "international rankings" section directly above. As for education spending, America is not first in the world, as many like to say (the U.S. is actually 5th in the world in straight out dollars spent per pupil on K-12 education). Importantly, almost all analysts agree that how much a country values education is not measured by straight out dollars spent but by the percentage of GDP spent on K-12 schools. GDP (gross domestic product) is indicative of a nation's true wealth, and using percentage of GDP spent on public education, the U.S. is 63rd on "The World Factbook" list of 173 nations.
Link to: Nations and percent of GDP spent on education
FALSE CLAIM: Terrible graduation rates are proof that our public schools have failed.
The 1940s and 1950s are often referred to as the golden age of public schools. Well, the graduation rate for U.S. public schools in the 1940s was 51% and in the 1950s it was 62%. The graduation rate for U.S. public schools in 2014 was 82% (that's the latest rate available and highest rate since a uniform calculation method was adopted).
Variant type high schools were created in many instances as answers to failed public high schools. Such variant secondary schools include charter high schools, alternative high schools, and virtual high schools. Those variant high schools all dragged down the national graduation average (for 2014: regular public high schools 85%, charter high schools 70%, alternative high schools 52%, virtual high schools 40%).
Link to: Recent national graduation rates
Link to: Historical view of national graduation rates
FALSE CLAIM: Lousy public schools cause the "achievement gap" between white and minority students.
The achievement gap goes to the heart of not only our public schools' biggest problem but America's biggest problem - POVERTY. And, since it is such a defining issue, this stands as the most developed response in "A Public Defense of the Public Schools".
This achievement gap claim is a half truth. Yes, there is an achievement gap between whites and minority students (mostly black) but it is NOT caused by lousy public schools. Instead, this gap is mostly caused by poverty (and somewhat by the cultural bias that exists with achievement tests). "Poverty gap", rather than "achievement gap", would be a better description for the differences between white and minority students.
Public schools do not create the neighborhoods and environments in which they exist, they mirror them.
As studies show, when a family's income rises, so do the test scores of children in that family. For every additional $10,000 of family income, a person on average gains 30 points on the SAT. Educational researcher, David Berliner, states that thousands of studies have linked poverty to academic achievement. The relationship is every bit as strong as the connection between cigarettes and cancer. Yet, school reform ignores this truth by demanding equality in achievement with no consideration for U.S. children living below the poverty line. The futility of reforming schools while ignoring poverty is best summed up by political economist, Jean Anyon, "Attempting to fix inner-city schools without fixing the city is like trying to clean the air on one side of a screen door."
Sadly, poverty is not being thwarted. Data from the U.S. Department of Education shows that, for the first time in history, American public schools reported more than one million homeless students. The latest U.S. Census reports 48.5 million Americans (16.8 million children) living in poverty - the largest number in the 53 year history of published poverty data. UNICEF showed 32% of U.S. children in poverty with America ranking 36th out of the 41 wealthy countries included in the report. And, the National Center for Education Statistics reports 51% of students in America's public schools are from low income families.
If any faith can be put into international comparisons, American students are right at the top when U.S. child poverty levels are factored in (as they should be when trying to make valid, statistical comparisons).
Still, with the HUGE amount of students in poverty and what we know relative to poverty and school achievement, public school foes still shout, "NO EXCUSES! Quit using poverty as an excuse for low school achievement." However, excuses come in two forms: bad excuses and good excuses. If someone runs over a person's dog because he or she was texting, then that's a bad excuse. But, if the dog was run over due to mechanical brake failure, then that's a good excuse. If impoverished students do poorly because public schools don't care and teachers are inept and lazy, then that's a bad excuse. But, if low achievement happens due to the effects of poverty (poor nutrition, higher rates of vision/hearing problems, less opportunity for proper health care, higher mobility rate, weak foundation of educational experiences at home, more infants exposed to tobacco, alcohol, drugs, poor nutrition during prenatal development, etc.) then that's a good excuse.
Link to: Academic performance and poverty
Link to: Minority testing bias
I have a B.S. and M.S. in Education and was a public school teacher for over 30 years. I am now retired. Early in my career, the organized attack on public schools was launched and it's still being aggressively waged today. The attackers are well-funded and their bogus
message of public school failure is consistent, well-stated, highly publicized
and regrettably, quite successful.
Oddly,
almost every major issue in America has its partisan divide but not so with
public schools. With conservatives/liberals, Republicans/Democrats, left/right,
red/blue or however it can be stated, a remarkable reality exists – both sides
seem to agree that our public schools are failing. I confess the attackers
even had me convinced, even though when I was teaching my own experiences did not support that
reality. I just figured my own school district, colleagues, and students were islands of
success in the great ocean of failed public schools.
However, once I questioned the great claim of system wide public school failure, an abundance of contrary evidence was discovered. That’s when “A Public Defense of the Public Schools” was fashioned. Since 2005, I have delivered my “defense” to conferences, civic groups, and educators.
FALSE CLAIM: Public schools are failing because tenure laws protects bad teachers.
In most school districts tenure is not granted until 5 years of teaching have been completed. Certainly by that time an incompetent teacher should have been identified.
Teacher tenure only ensures a teacher be given a fair hearing before getting fired. However, public school attackers have made "tenure" a dirty word. A majority of respondents, when asked in a Zogby Poll if they supported tenure, respond with, "No". However, when asked if they supported replacing tenure with a system where a teacher received a fair hearing before a school board could fire them, 84% of respondents replied with a strong, "Yes". Of course what respondents said "yes" to was a basic definition of teacher tenure.
FALSE CLAIM: U.S. students have fallen far from the top of the world rankings.
U.S. students were never at or near the top on international comparisons and such comparisons are arguably meaningless.
With so many variables, a valid comparison of students from various countries is a tricky and statistically challenging analysis.
Actually, just about any conclusion, good or bad, regarding American public school students and their international ranking can be drawn using selective data and/or biased interpretations. Foes of American public schools often use singular hand-picked results to support their "school crisis" rhetoric.
The two links posted below give a great understanding of the complexity and perhaps the futility of trying to make accurate statements about U.S. students vs. their international counterparts.
Link to: What international tests really show
Link to: Important considerations regarding international test scores
FALSE CLAIM: America outspends all other nations on public schools yet still has nothing to show for it.
As for poor results, refer to the "international rankings" section directly above. As for education spending, America is not first in the world, as many like to say (the U.S. is actually 5th in the world in straight out dollars spent per pupil on K-12 education). Importantly, almost all analysts agree that how much a country values education is not measured by straight out dollars spent but by the percentage of GDP spent on K-12 schools. GDP (gross domestic product) is indicative of a nation's true wealth, and using percentage of GDP spent on public education, the U.S. is 63rd on "The World Factbook" list of 173 nations.
Link to: Nations and percent of GDP spent on education
FALSE CLAIM: Terrible graduation rates are proof that our public schools have failed.
The 1940s and 1950s are often referred to as the golden age of public schools. Well, the graduation rate for U.S. public schools in the 1940s was 51% and in the 1950s it was 62%. The graduation rate for U.S. public schools in 2014 was 82% (that's the latest rate available and highest rate since a uniform calculation method was adopted).
Variant type high schools were created in many instances as answers to failed public high schools. Such variant secondary schools include charter high schools, alternative high schools, and virtual high schools. Those variant high schools all dragged down the national graduation average (for 2014: regular public high schools 85%, charter high schools 70%, alternative high schools 52%, virtual high schools 40%).
Link to: Recent national graduation rates
Link to: Historical view of national graduation rates
FALSE CLAIM: Lousy public schools cause the "achievement gap" between white and minority students.
The achievement gap goes to the heart of not only our public schools' biggest problem but America's biggest problem - POVERTY. And, since it is such a defining issue, this stands as the most developed response in "A Public Defense of the Public Schools".
This achievement gap claim is a half truth. Yes, there is an achievement gap between whites and minority students (mostly black) but it is NOT caused by lousy public schools. Instead, this gap is mostly caused by poverty (and somewhat by the cultural bias that exists with achievement tests). "Poverty gap", rather than "achievement gap", would be a better description for the differences between white and minority students.
Public schools do not create the neighborhoods and environments in which they exist, they mirror them.
As studies show, when a family's income rises, so do the test scores of children in that family. For every additional $10,000 of family income, a person on average gains 30 points on the SAT. Educational researcher, David Berliner, states that thousands of studies have linked poverty to academic achievement. The relationship is every bit as strong as the connection between cigarettes and cancer. Yet, school reform ignores this truth by demanding equality in achievement with no consideration for U.S. children living below the poverty line. The futility of reforming schools while ignoring poverty is best summed up by political economist, Jean Anyon, "Attempting to fix inner-city schools without fixing the city is like trying to clean the air on one side of a screen door."
Sadly, poverty is not being thwarted. Data from the U.S. Department of Education shows that, for the first time in history, American public schools reported more than one million homeless students. The latest U.S. Census reports 48.5 million Americans (16.8 million children) living in poverty - the largest number in the 53 year history of published poverty data. UNICEF showed 32% of U.S. children in poverty with America ranking 36th out of the 41 wealthy countries included in the report. And, the National Center for Education Statistics reports 51% of students in America's public schools are from low income families.
If any faith can be put into international comparisons, American students are right at the top when U.S. child poverty levels are factored in (as they should be when trying to make valid, statistical comparisons).
Still, with the HUGE amount of students in poverty and what we know relative to poverty and school achievement, public school foes still shout, "NO EXCUSES! Quit using poverty as an excuse for low school achievement." However, excuses come in two forms: bad excuses and good excuses. If someone runs over a person's dog because he or she was texting, then that's a bad excuse. But, if the dog was run over due to mechanical brake failure, then that's a good excuse. If impoverished students do poorly because public schools don't care and teachers are inept and lazy, then that's a bad excuse. But, if low achievement happens due to the effects of poverty (poor nutrition, higher rates of vision/hearing problems, less opportunity for proper health care, higher mobility rate, weak foundation of educational experiences at home, more infants exposed to tobacco, alcohol, drugs, poor nutrition during prenatal development, etc.) then that's a good excuse.
Link to: Academic performance and poverty
Link to: Minority testing bias
![]() |
| email: macnagle@aol.com 309/532-4740 |
However, once I questioned the great claim of system wide public school failure, an abundance of contrary evidence was discovered. That’s when “A Public Defense of the Public Schools” was fashioned. Since 2005, I have delivered my “defense” to conferences, civic groups, and educators.

